这篇文章介绍了critical writing的意义,和写好critical writing的准则,最后介绍了在critical writing中常见的句式。对于这类写作非常有帮助。
critical writing怎么写
Critical essay writing的意义为批判性写作。广义的critical writing指的是运用批判性思维的技术和方法进行写作的一种写作方式。狭义的critical writing指的是一种评估性写作,根据批判性思维的一系列准则对给出的论证的可靠性进行评估,并写出分析评估报告。狭义的性写作又称分析性写作,属于类似写评估报告那样的应用文写作。
批判性阅读就是针对论证的主张,考问其理由的真实性或可信性以及推理的有效性,鉴别论证中可能存在的种种谬误,对你所读到或听到的信息做出积极主动的反应。批判性阅读是分析性写作的基础,反过来说,分析性写作就是撰写批判性阅读的读书报告。
在critical writing中药注意使用宽容原则和中立原则。宽容原则用于对给出的论证的理解,指的是以合理性的最大限度来理解论证的原则。中立原则用于对给出的论证的评估,指的是以批判性准则来评估论证的原则。
在critical writing中要分别从主张、理由和推理三个方面重温评估论证的准则,基于这些准则需要做出哪些批判性反应,以及检查在论证中可能会出现哪些谬误。
critical essay writing句型
提出理论或论据时可以用到的critical essay语句:
There are a number of strengths/weaknesses etc with this theory/argument.Firstly---Secondly---More/most importantly/significantly---.
A(particular/important)strength of this is---
One/a further(major/key)criticism of Smith’s work is that---
A(serious)weakness/problem with this theory/argument/viewpoint/explanation/proposal/interpretation is that---
However,this fails to/does not appear to take account of---
What Smith fails to do is---
Smith fails to fully acknowledge the importance of/need for---etc
Smith offers no explanation for/omits to explain/mention---
This could be challenged on the basis that---
This relies too heavily on/places too much emphasis on---
A counter argument might be that---
It might be argued,however,that---
An alternative explanation might be that---
One question that might need to be asked is---
It is questionable whether---
There is an inconsistency in this argument:---
An apparent inconsistency/omission is that---
Smith contradicts himself in this when he states that---
This argument/theory etc does not/fails to stand up to scrutiny when considering---
This is/would not be appropriate in situations/cases where---
There are/could be difficulties/limitations with applying this in practice,however.
This could present difficulties in practice.For example---
The practical implications of this need to be carefully considered.
Implementation of this has not been without/has presented(considerable/numerous/some)difficulties.
与实践/方法/模型有关的critical essay句型:
This has/had the benefit/positive effect/advantage of---
A positive outcome of this was---
This appears to have been successful largely because–
This method/approach is particularly/mainly appropriate/useful in cases/circumstances where---
One/another problem/disadvantage/drawback with this method/approach is/was that---
This model/method/approach does/did not address/take account of---
Perhaps the most serious disadvantage/limitation of this method is---
There are a number of limitations when following this approach/using this method/model.
This method/model has a number of limitations/disadvantages
This method/approach does not lend itself to cases/situations where---
引用他人的评论句型:
This has been criticised/challenged by–
Critics(Smith,2008;Jones,2009)have argued that---
Many/some have challenged this on the grounds that---
提出建设性意见时用到的语句:
A better/more systematic study would---
It would be/would have been better/more beneficial/appropriate/useful/effective to---
A better/more helpful etc approach/method etc would be/have been to---
The X approach/model would be/have been more appropriate/beneficial in this case/these circumstances.
This situation/these circumstances would lend itself/themselves better to the X model/approach.
Further explanation/clarification/research is required/recommended.
以上这些critical essay句型在进行critical essay writing中非常实用。